Home page
Inquiry Objectives
Holyrood History
News and Updates
Schedule
Transcripts and Documents
Link to TV coverage
Contact Us
Conducted by The Rt Hon The Lord Fraser of Carmyllie QC
News and updates banner

To read DOCUMENTS in PDF format you will need a copy of the freely available Adobe Acrobat Reader.

Evidence submitted to the Holyrood Inquiry by: Scottish Executive

Scottish Executive - Procurement

Date:

Originator:

Addressee:

Subject:

Inquiry Reference
File:

September 1994

The Scottish Office Building Directorate

The Scottish Office

Consultant Selection & Fee Tendering – Practice Note 5

SE/5/621 – 644

1997

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance - No.1  Essential Requirements for Construction Procurement

SE/5/368 - 398

1997

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance - No.2  Value for Money in Construction Procurement

SE/5/399 - 420

June 1992

HM Treasury – Central Unit on Purchasing

-

No. 36 Contract Strategy Selection for Major Projects

SE/5/348 - 367

July 1995

HM Treasury

-

Paper – An Introduction to the EC Procurement Rule

SE/5/596 - 614

19 May 1997

Brian Peddie

Alistair Brown

Minute – Accommodation Aspects of a Scottish Parliament

SE/5/019 - 020

20 June 1997

John Graham

Paul Grice

Minute – Scottish Parliament Costs

SE/5/008

December 1997

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance – No.3 Appointment of Consultants and Contractors

SE/5/421 – 448

4 December 1997

John Graham

Alistair Brown

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building: Choice of Location

SE/5/005 – 006

19 December 1997

John Graham

Alistair Brown

Minute - Scottish Parliament Building: Choice of Location

SE/5/007

31 December 1997

John Graham

Robert Gordon

Minute and draft submission – Scottish Parliament Building: Procurement

SE/5/009 - 018

31 December 1997

Alistair Brown

Robert Gordon

E-mail – Scottish Parliament Building Procurement

SE/5/026

6 January 1998

Robert Gordon

PS/Mr McLeish

PS/Secretary of State

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building: Procurement

SE/5/043 – 050

6 January 1998

Brian Whitehead

 

APC Lecture Notes – What is construction management?

SE/5/057 - 067

13 January 1998

PS/Mr McLeish

PS/Secretary of State

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building: Procurement

SE/5/051

23 January 1998

Kenneth Thomson, PS/Secretary of State

Robert Gordon

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building:  Procurement

SE/5/052

6 February 1998

William Armstrong

Alistair Brown

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building

SE/5/068 - 069

9 February 1998

Alistair Brown

William Armstrong

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building – Procurement

SE/5/070

5 March 1998

Alistair Brown

William Armstrong

Minute – Scottish Parliament Building Procurement Route

SE/5/071

1 May 1998

Scottish Office

-

Scottish Office Finance Manual - Section T - Major Capital Expenditure Projects

SE/5/449 - 485

June 1998

The Scottish Office Building Directorate

No name

EC Public Services Contracts Regulations - Practice Note 7A

SE/5/645 - 673  

21 July 1998

Design Team Secretariat

 

Minutes of Design Team Meeting on 21 July 1998

SE/5/072 - 074

23 July 1998

Marie McDonald

Enric Miralles

Fax – Programme of Events for UK Visit

SE/5/677 – 678

28 July 1998

William Armstrong

Hugh Fisher

Amended Pre Qualification Questionnaire

SE/5/139 - 151

13 August 1998

Helen Ieronimo, DLE

Ian McAndie

Fax – OJEC Notice for Construction Management Services

SE/5/075 - 077

24 August 1998

William Armstrong

Barbara Doig

Minute – Holyrood: Construction Manager

SE/5/152

27 August 1998

Hugh Fisher

William Armstrong

Fax - Construction Management Costs

SE/5/153

September 1998

William Armstrong

 

Interview Agenda and Evaluation Sheets – Construction Management Services Appointment

SE/5/083 - 086

11 September 1998

Alastair Wyllie

Barbara Doig

Minute – Holyrood Construction Management Services

SE/5/154 - 155

15 September 1998

Eric Kinsey

John Gibbons

Barbara Doig

Minute – Construction Management Services

SE/5/078R

15 September 1998

Ian McAndie

 

Pre qualification questionnaire for Sir Robert McAlpine

SE/5/164 - 165

15 September 1998

Jim Fairclough

 

Pre qualification questionnaire for Sir Robert McAlpine

SE/5/166 -167

15 September 1998

Ian McAndie

 

Pre qualification questionnaire for Bovis

SE/5/168 – 169

15 September 1998

Jim Fairclough

 

Pre qualification questionnaire for Bovis

SE/5/170 -171

24 September 1998

Jim Fairclough

-

File Note – Construction Management Services

SE/5/618

25 September 1998

Jim Fairclough

File

Minutes of Interview Panel on 25 September 1998 – Construction Management Services

SE/5/079R – 082R

25 September 1998

Enric Miralles

William Armstrong

Fax – MSP Block

SE/5/688

29 September 1998

John Kinsley

Design Team

Faxed Minute of Design Team Meeting on 29 September 1998

SE/5/689 - 692

October 1998

Holyrood Building Team

 

Paper on Conclusions of the Construction Management Appointment Interviews on 6 and 7 October 1998

SE/5/087R – 092R

5 October 1998

Enric Miralles

William Armstrong

Letter – construction manager

SE/5/178

7 October 1998

Jim Fairclough

 

File Note – Initial conclusions of interview panel

SE/5/190R – 191R

8 October 1998

William Armstrong

Ian McAndie

Letter – Construction Management Services

SE/5/179 – 180

8 October 1998

William Armstrong

Design Team

Letter – Construction Management Services

SE/5/181R

9 October 1998

Drew Elliot

William Armstrong

Fax – Construction Management Services

SE/5/192

9 October 1998

Ian McAndie

William Armstrong

Fax – Construction Manager

SE/5/193

9 October 1998

Jim Fairclough

William Armstrong

Email – CMS Bovis Team

SE/5/194

9 October 1998

Alan Mack

Jim Fairclough

Letter – Scottish Parliament Building – Construction Management Services

SE/5/195

9 October 1998

Ian McAndie

William Armstrong

Fax – Construction Management Fees and Charges

SE/5/196

9 October 1998

William Armstrong

Enric Miralles

Benedetta Tagliabue

Fax – Scottish Parliament Building

SE/5/674 - 676

9 October 1998

John Kinsley

William Armstrong

Fax – Stage C Report

SE/5/679

13 October 1998

Helen Strachan

John Kinsley

Faxes -  from Enric Miralles to William Armstrong

SE/5/680 - 686

13 October 1998

Jim Fairclough

DAS

Minute – Construction Management Services for Holyrood

SE/5/197

21 October 1998

Enric Miralles

William Armstrong

Fax – Drawings to Quantity Surveyor

SE/5/687

November 1998

DLE

Scottish Office

DLE Review of Construction Management Tenders - November 1998

SE/5/096

SE/5/097

SE/5/098R

SE/5/099R

SE/5/100R

SE/5/101R

SE/5/102R

SE/5/102A(R)

23 November 1998

William Armstrong

Barbara Doig

Minute – Holyrood Construction Manager

SE/5/093

23 November 1998

Barbara Doig

William Armstrong

Minute – Construction Manager

SE/5/094

27 November 1998

Jim Fairclough

 

Construction Management Confidential Tender Information

SE/5/095R

2 December 1998

Holyrood Building Team

 

Minutes of Meeting on 2 December 1998 to Evaluate Tenders for Construction Management Services

SE/5/103R – 104R

3 December 1998

Alan Tweedie

William Armstrong

Fax – Construction Managers

SE/5/200

9 December 1998

Barbara Doig

William Armstrong

Minute – Construction Manager Interviews

SE/5/105

9 December 1998

Barbara Doig

Enric Miralles

Letter – Construction Manager Interviews

SE/5/202

15 December 1998

Barbara Doig

William Armstrong

Minute – Construction Manager Appointment

SE/5/106

15 December 1998

William Armstrong

Barbara Doig

Minute - Construction Management Appointment

SE/5/107R

16 December 1998

Barbara Doig

William Armstrong

Minute – Construction Management Appointment

SE/5/108

16 December 1998

Jim Fairclough

Gordon Ash

Letter - Construction Management Services

SE/5/204 – 205

17 December 1998

John Anderson, Bovis

William Armstrong

Letter - Holyrood Construction Management Services

SE/5/206

18 December 1998

Paul Whitehill

Jim Fairclough

Fax – Health and safety construction manager

SE/5/207, 208R & 209R

23 December 1998

Ian McAndie

RL Spring - Bovis

Fax - Holyrood construction management tender

SE/5/210

24 December 1998

Harry Thorburn

Ian McAndie

Letter – Construction Management Tender

SE/5/211

4 January 1999

Holyrood Parliament Project Team

 

Minutes – Notes of final interviews for construction management services

SE/5/120R – 125

4 January 1999

Interview Panel

 

Evaluation sheets

SE/5/212 – 270

4 January 1999

Jim Fairclough

 

Summary of Evaluation Sheets

SE/5/271R

6 January 1999

Harry Thorburn

Ian McAndie, DLE

Letter - Construction Management Tender

SE/5/273 – 275

7 January 1999

Hugh Fisher

Barbara Doig

Letter and Report  – Scottish Parliament Building Construction Management Bids

SE/5/109 -119

7 January 1999

Jim Fairclough

Gordon Ash, Bovis Construction

Letter – Scottish Parliament Building  Construction Management Services

SE/5/126

7 January 1999 (incorrectly dated)

Gordon Ash, Bovis

Jim Fairclough

Letter – Construction Management Services

SE/5/276

19 January 1999

Barbara Doig

Gordon Ash,

Bovis Construction

Letter – Scottish Parliament Building -  Construction Management Services

SE/5/135 – 136

1 February 1999

Alan Mack

Barbara Doig

Letter – Scottish Parliament Building Holyrood

SE/5/137 - 138

19 May 1999

Dr Peter Collings, Principal Finance Officer

Mr McConnell, Minister for Finance

Minute - Holyrood Parliament Building Costs and Parliament Running Costs

SE/5/616 - 617

June 1999

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance – No.4 Team Working, Partnering and Incentives

SE/5/507 – 519

June 1999

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance – No.5 Procurement Strategies

SE/5/520 – 530

June 1999

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance – No.6 Financial Aspects of Projects

SE/5/531 – 541

1 June 1999

Michael Kellet, PS/Deputy First Minister

PS/First Minister

E-mail – Holyrood Building – Budget Review

SE/5/615

July 1999

Scottish Enterprise

-

Report: Knowledge Management in Construction & Environmental Projects – Procurement Best Practice

SE/5/542 - 595

December 1999

HM Treasury – Procurement Group

-

Procurement Guidance - Supplementary Guidance to PG1 on the Role of the Project Sponsor

SE/5/486 - 506

20 April 2000

Scottish Executive Internal Audit Unit

Internal Audit Report – Holyrood Parliament Building Project

SE/5/326 - 347

27 October 2003

John Graham

Holyrood Inquiry

John S Graham – Witness Statement

SE/5/001 – 004

28 October 2003

Mark Batho

Holyrood Inquiry

Mark Batho – Witness Statement

SE/5/022 - 024

 
Footnote:
Material has been removed from this document that is either not relevant to the Inquiry's remit or is commercially sensitive.

Documents recently added to the Inquiry website.

Return to 'FULL DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE' menu


 
Return to top of page
Website designed and managed by
Media2k